Download
as a pdf »
Greenspan Versus the Postal Service
August 2003
Alan Greenspan’s policy of startlingly low interest
rates may well cause postal revenues to drop. Any good
capitalist knows about the “time value of money” but
few realize just how far the concept can go when interest
rates are this low. To clarify, consider the fact that
one is currently better off prepaying by one year any
monthly household bill less than $52.86 because the
money saved on 12 stamps is greater than the earnings
on one’s own cash. (Assume 0.7% money market
return and no value to either your time or the envelope.)
We have little interest in the postal service, but
allow us to explore why interest rates are so low and
the related variables influencing investors at this
time. We believe Alan Greenspan is keeping rates so
low because he must encourage the global economy to
grow. He especially wants to see U. S. consumers bolstered
by low mortgage rates and he welcomes the fact that
low interest rates refuel our banking system’s
capital base. Low interest rates are part of his easy
money policy for growth, but also reflect the deflationary
impacts of globalization (cheap labor) and technology-driven
productivity, which have both held inflation in check.
Ideally, life goes merrily along with low interest
rates, stable currencies and low inflation. However,
a risk we face going forward is the likelihood that
federal and state budget deficits will be financed
via borrowing. By our reckoning, the U. S. must borrow
another trillion dollars in the next few years to keep
the global economy percolating. While interest rates
are low now due to tepid growth and a flight to safety
by bondholders, it is very possible that rates may
have to rise appreciably in order to attract investors.
This has certainly started to happen over the last
few weeks.
To protect against possible higher rates, we have allowed
the average maturity of our clients’ bond portfolios
to drift to the low point of a 3-5 year targeted range.
We have also selectively liquidated some long-dated
bonds. As rates rise, we will extend these maturities
accordingly. “Patience is a virtue” in
this fixed income market and we are not trying to “reach” for
yield at this time.
Rising interest rates are not typically good for the
stock market. However, we expect to see that rule violated.
For one, higher interest rates may be accompanied by
improved global growth. This growth should translate
to higher than expected profits by large companies
with the right global reach (not every Blue Chip will
play its global cards properly). For example, the emergence
of new consumers by the billions over the next 20 years
will provide continued growth opportunities for companies
such as Coca-Cola, Colgate-Palmolive and many of the
other Blue Chip stocks we own. Please note as well
that interest rates can rise from here, yet still remain
well below historic norms.
As discussed in our last newsletter, another rule likely
to be broken is the historic one which connects a good
stock market with strong employment in the United States.
Unfortunately, tomorrow’s global prosperity may
mean that millions of Americans lose high paying jobs
or see their pay collapse by 10%-20%. Ford (not on
our Buy List) has announced 10% pay cuts across the
board and some predict that millions of computer technology
and software jobs will leave the United States in the
next ten years for low cost (and high expertise) places
like Russia, China and India.
Selected stocks may do very well in the face of possible
higher interest rates and a poor domestic employment
outlook. Notice the emphasis on the word “selected” in
the prior sentence. It is important to note that the
crosscurrents from global growth that we foresee will
benefit some companies but certainly hurt others. Our
advice is to sell the Blue Chips that are screaming
for more protectionism and buy those that are learning
how to speak Chinese.
We expect a “stock picker’s market” where
not every large company does well simply because it
is large. This is reflected already in the fact that
we have been able to outperform index funds (which
must own all large stocks) over the last three years.
Fortunately for our clients, our size allows us to
deftly own just 30-35 of those companies that meet
our proprietary screens for quality, growth and management
integrity. We also employ a global equity manager for
wider diversified global exposure.
As for dividends, we see opportunity but have words
of caution as well. The reduction in the tax on dividends
is welcomed. Previously, and too often, companies viewed
enhancement of their Wall Street “image” a
more valuable strategy than the production of cash.
Our stock selection process has always rewarded a company’s
ability to produce cash relative to its market value
as a key fundamental (that’s how we avoided so
many of the popular stock meltdowns). A warning to
investors, though, is to let the market settle down
a little and allow historically low dividend paying
companies to increase their dividends. Avoid jumping
on a high yield too soon, only to own low growth, or
a tainted company, as a result.
In conclusion, save some time and stamps and prepay
the milkman if you want to maximize returns. Who knows,
maybe the Postmaster General will “one up” Greenspan
and drop stamp prices! Secondly, celebrate the fact
that we no longer count China and Russia as enemies
and be prepared for global competition over jobs. The
global pie will grow, creating tremendous investment
opportunities if one is careful.
Your comments and questions
are always welcomed.
Andrew C. Burns
President/Chief Investment Officer
« Return to top
of page
This website and the material
presented on it are for informational purposes only
and should not be construed as personalized investment
advice or as a solicitation or recommendation to
buy or sell securities. Please see full
disclosure. |